How this Trial of a Former Soldier Regarding the 1972 Londonderry Incident Ended in Not Guilty Verdict

Protesters in a tense situation with army troops on Bloody Sunday
Youths in a tense situation with military personnel on Bloody Sunday

January 30th, 1972 stands as arguably the most deadly – and consequential – dates during thirty years of unrest in Northern Ireland.

Within the community where events unfolded – the legacy of the tragic events are painted on the structures and seared in collective memory.

A protest demonstration was held on a chilly yet clear afternoon in the city.

The demonstration was challenging the system of detention without trial – detaining individuals without due process – which had been put in place after multiple years of violence.

Father Daly displayed a bloodied fabric while attempting to defend a assembly carrying a young man, Jackie Duddy
A Catholic priest displayed a blood-stained handkerchief while attempting to protect a group moving a youth, Jackie Duddy

Troops from the Parachute Regiment killed multiple civilians in the district – which was, and continues to be, a overwhelmingly Irish nationalist population.

One image became particularly memorable.

Pictures showed a Catholic priest, Fr Edward Daly, waving a blood-stained white handkerchief in his effort to shield a group carrying a young man, the injured teenager, who had been mortally injured.

Journalists recorded considerable film on the day.

The archive features the priest explaining to a reporter that military personnel "gave the impression they would shoot indiscriminately" and he was "completely sure" that there was no reason for the shooting.

Civilians in the district being marched towards custody by soldiers on Bloody Sunday
Protesters in the Bogside area being taken to arrest by military personnel on Bloody Sunday

The narrative of events wasn't accepted by the initial investigation.

The Widgery Tribunal found the military had been attacked first.

During the resolution efforts, the ruling party established another inquiry, after campaigning by bereaved relatives, who said Widgery had been a inadequate investigation.

During 2010, the conclusion by Lord Saville said that on balance, the paratroopers had initiated shooting and that zero among the victims had posed any threat.

At that time government leader, the Prime Minister, issued an apology in the government chamber – declaring deaths were "unjustified and unacceptable."

Kin of the casualties of the 1972 incident fatalities march from the Bogside area of Londonderry to the civic building holding pictures of their relatives
Kin of the deceased of the Bloody Sunday fatalities walk from the district of Derry to the municipal center displaying photographs of their relatives

Law enforcement started to investigate the incident.

One former paratrooper, known as the defendant, was prosecuted for murder.

Indictments were filed over the fatalities of the first individual, in his twenties, and twenty-six-year-old William McKinney.

The defendant was further implicated of trying to kill Patrick O'Donnell, Joseph Friel, Joe Mahon, another person, and an unnamed civilian.

Remains a court ruling preserving the defendant's anonymity, which his lawyers have claimed is required because he is at danger.

He told the examination that he had exclusively discharged his weapon at people who were possessing firearms.

That claim was disputed in the final report.

Information from the inquiry would not be used directly as testimony in the court case.

During the trial, the veteran was shielded from sight using a privacy screen.

He made statements for the initial occasion in the hearing at a proceeding in December 2024, to answer "not responsible" when the allegations were read.

Family members and supporters of those killed on Bloody Sunday carry a placard and photographs of those killed
Kin and allies of the victims on Bloody Sunday display a banner and photos of the deceased

Family members of the deceased on that day made the trip from Derry to the courthouse each day of the case.

One relative, whose sibling was fatally wounded, said they understood that attending the proceedings would be emotional.

"I visualize all details in my recollection," the relative said, as we examined the primary sites mentioned in the trial – from the street, where the victim was fatally wounded, to the nearby Glenfada Park, where James Wray and William McKinney were killed.

"It reminds me to where I was that day.

"I assisted with the victim and place him in the medical transport.

"I experienced again the entire event during the evidence.

"Despite having to go through everything – it's still meaningful for me."

One victim (left) and Another victim (right) were included who were killed on the incident
Jeremy Becker
Jeremy Becker

A passionate traveler and writer sharing insights on off-the-beaten-path destinations and sustainable tourism.